Why can there be two similar cards when adding a set?
When bulk-adding a TCG card set in Cardstashr you may notice what looks like duplicate entries for the same card. This happens because TCGPlayer lists separate products for different card variants, meaning a normal print and a holofoil of the same card are distinct items.
1TCGPlayer Variant-Based Product Listings Explained
TCGPlayer treats each card variant including normal, foil, reverse holo, and secret rare as a separate product with its own unique product ID and market data.
2Different Variants Are Separate Products
Two identical-looking cards are actually separate collectibles. A standard print and a holofoil version of the same card are distinct products in the TCGPlayer catalog.
3Both Variants Are Valid Collection Entries in Cardstashr
Cardstashr adds each variant as its own binder entry so you can independently track ownership for every version of a card you collect.
Duplicate-looking cards in Cardstashr represent real product variants in the TCGPlayer marketplace. Tracking each variant separately gives you accurate collection tracking and precise organization.